How to Evaluate Cultural Traditions, and Practices

How to Evaluate Cultural Traditions, and Practices

By Richard W. Greene

As we work with people and groups from many different religious and cultural back grounds, we often encounter practices, traditions, and beliefs that are very different from our own. Some are good and express the beauty and positive character of the people. Others may not be good, and may, in fact, be very detrimental to those who practice them. How can we, as disciples of Christ, properly assess these things? Here are some key things we must evaluate to determine the biblical acceptability of any religious or cultural practice.

1. What does Scripture say about it?
   1. Is this practice mentioned in the Bible?
      1. Is it mentioned directly or illustrated?
      1. Is it mentioned in a list of other activities?
      1. Is it compared to other activities?
   1. What does the Bible say about this practice?
   1. Are there examples of this activity being practiced by individuals or groups?
   1. Is the activity viewed favorably or unfavorably?
2. What is the source of this practice?
   1. Source determines nature (John 3:6).
   1. Is it from the Spirit (holy) or the flesh (common)?
   1. Does it involve an occultic act or artifact?
   1. Was it commanded, given, or directed by God?
   1. Is it pure or syncretistic (mixed) in its current form?
   1. Has it been corrupted from its original nature?
   1. If corrupted, can it be redeemed?
   1. How does this practice reflect Christ and His will?
3. What is the purpose and use of this practice?
   1. Is the primary purpose of this practice religious or is it common (non-religious)? Is it necessary?
   1. Is it an “old thing” of the world, or is it a “new thing” of the Spirit (2 Corinthians 5:17-21)?
   1. Does the practice do something apart from God that God should be doing in your life?
   1. Is it used to promote God’s designs and purposes?
   1. Does this practice serve others or is it self-gratifying?
4. What is the effect of this practice?
   1. Does this thing reveal and honor Christ?
   1. Does it glorify God?
   1. Does it divide people or unite them (Acts 15:13-29)?
   1. Does it generate holiness and character?
   1. Is it a fruit of the Spirit or a work of the flesh?
   1. Does it bind me to unbelievers (2 Corinthians 6:14-18)?
   1. Does it offend other believers (Romans 14)?